The
following response to the Charlottesville tragedy stems from conversations with
two friends. One who is far right and
another who is far left. I am thankful
for both of them in my life!
I am someone who has come to have great empathy for minorities. However, I believe I also need to develop empathy for the KKK as well. In their own way they are oppressed. Their behavior is irrational and that stems from fear. Until I begin to try and understand that fear, I will just continue to revolve in the same cycle. Moreover, I believe that I am not the only one with this problem.
I am someone who has come to have great empathy for minorities. However, I believe I also need to develop empathy for the KKK as well. In their own way they are oppressed. Their behavior is irrational and that stems from fear. Until I begin to try and understand that fear, I will just continue to revolve in the same cycle. Moreover, I believe that I am not the only one with this problem.
How
do we use our moral imagination to find creative solutions rather than dig our
heels into "our side"? Questions to the protesters maybe: What is
your favorite hobby? What is your favorite sport? Or perhaps offer them
something cold to drink. Find some kind
of common ground somehow which will allow each side to humanize the other--I
seriously doubt that the anti-protesters in Charlottesville were able to see
past the hate from those they were protesting.
Therefore, they were incapable of recognizing the humanity of those they
came to protest against and, if we are honest, that really makes them not that
far removed from what it was that they were protesting—they see the hate, which
causes fear. Then that fear is transformed into their own anger which is then
transformed into their own hate which makes dehumanization the logical next
step.
When
I went to the protest on immigration earlier this year outside of the Supreme
Court building in Washington DC I was frustrated. There were all of these jokes
at the expense of 45. I was frustrated with myself because I felt a nudge
inside me that wanted to be part of the crowd response to dehumanize 45. I did
not participate in those chants but there was a strong part of me that wanted
to and disgustingly I did laugh at a few. I was also frustrated with those that
did choose to participate; for them failing to recognize that they really were
not any different from what they were protesting--As Dr. King states "an
injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." And the
dehumanizing of any human is an injustice. That protest became more about what
we were against rather than what we were for—In essence we became exactly what
it was that we were protesting against. That mob mentality is counterproductive
and dangerous as it stems out of fear and anger rather than love.
One
of the many things I and admire, respect and love about Dr. King was that his
actions and organizing always came from a place of love and humanizing the
other. He said, the ends never justify the means, because ends are found in the
means. Our means must always begin from a place that resemble what we want our
ends to be.
Good thoughts, Steve. Certainly worth wrestling with in general with social media vibes but more so with mob crowd mentality... but i do think there is also a time to say 'this is not okay' and sometimes to stop something that is really not okay that has to be louder and perhaps even more forceful than a polite note or offer of a drink...
ReplyDeletei don't believe in violence as a solution but i guess if i saw a big kid beating up a smaller kid i would do my best to physically restrain the big kid which might feel like violence to the big kid...
Glad that you're causing us to think more deeply on this stuff but not sure what the answer is because for too long whites as a whole have done relatively nothing to say 'that is not okay' to the people that the not okay is being done to... so we need to view these things in the context of that as well...